Bonnell Spring vs Coir Mattress – 2 Confessions of an User

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp

QUICK COMPARISON

Prices and images pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Are you confused between bonnell spring vs coir mattress? A bonnell spring mattress is made of springs shaped like an hour-glass which are interconnected by metals at the top and the bottom. A coir mattress is made from natural coconut fibres. There is a huge difference between the two in materials alone. Let us find out who is the winner. 

Process of Comparing Between Bonnell Spring Mattress and Coir Mattress

The main difference between a bonnell spring mattress and a coir mattress is the material.

A bonnell spring mattress is made of steel springs. A coir mattress is made from coconut fibres, a natural product.

How can we ever compare between two mattresses when the primary materials are different?

We decided to compare two actual mattresses, one made from bonnell spring and the other a coir mattress.

The brands are – Coirfit for the bonnell mattress and Extra Sleep for the coir mattress.

Bonnell Spring Vs Coir Mattress Test

The comparison between a bonnell spring mattress and a coir mattress is difficult because the primary materials are very different to each other.

We still went ahead and tested the Coirfit bonnell spring mattress and the Extra Sleep coir mattress with the standard tests.

Let us see what the tests find out about them.

Test 1

Material

Coirfit has 31 years of experience in the industry. It is based in Meerut. Coirfit manufactures different types of mattresses from coir, spring and foam. The springs in the Coirfit Bonnell Spring mattress is made from steel. The bonnell springs are of good quality. But the polyurethane foam on the top is of average quality.

3/5

Extra Sleep is based in Gurgaon. It manufactures a wide range of mattresses – coir, spring, memory foam and bonded foam. The Extra Sleep Premium coir mattress has coir in the middle layer. The rubberised coir is made from natural coconut fibre. the coir is of very good quality.

4/5

WinnerThe winner is Extra Sleep Coir mattress.

Test 2

Comfort

The Coirfit bonnell springs are felt when lying on the mattress. This should not have been the case if the foam on the top were of good quality.

2/5

The comfort of the Extra Sleep coir mattress is firm and as per coir mattress standards.

4/5

Winner

The bonnell spring mattress is not very comfortable.

Test 3

Sizes

The Coirfit bonnell spring mattress has only 30 readymade sizes available. The mattress has 6″ thickness.

2/5

The Extra Sleep coir mattress comes in 3 different thickness levels of 4″, 5″ and 6″. It is available in an amazing 72 different readymade sizes.

5/5

Winner

Extra Sleep Premium coir mattress exceeds our expectations in thickness and sizes test.

Test 4

Strength

The Coirfit bonnell spring mattress has good build quality.  

3/5

The Extra Sleep coir mattress has 3 layers beside the outer fabric. It has high density polyurethane foam at the base which prevents the mattress from skidding. The rubberised coir is the middle layer is a firm layer for body support. The top layer is made of polyurethane foam, a soft layer for comfort. All the 3 layers are then covered by a 100% cotton fabric. Excellent build quality.

5/5

Winner

The build quality of the Extra Sleep coir mattress is excellent.

Test 5

Warranty

The bonnell spring mattress from Coirfit comes with 6 years warranty.

4/5

The Extra Sleep mattress has 5 years warranty.

4/5

Winner

The Coirfit mattress is the winner here.

Test 6

Customer Support

Customers of Coirfit bonnell spring mattress are not happy. There are many complains from product quality to packaging and returns.

2/5

The customers of Extra Sleep coir mattress are very happy with the product, packaging, delivery and customer support.

4/5

Winner

Extra Sleep coir mattress is the winner again.

Test Result

Coirfit Bonnell Spring Mattress
Average Score 53%
Extra Sleep Coir Mattress
Average Score 87%

Extra Sleep coir mattress has won by a huge margin.

Pros and Cons of Bonnell Spring Mattress and Coir Mattress

Bonnell Spring

Pros

  • Warranty

Cons

  • Material
  • Sizes
  • Comfort
  • Strength
  • Customer Support

Coir Mattress

Pros

  • Material
  • Comfort
  • Sizes
  • Strength
  • Customer Support

Cons

  • Warranty

Which One Should You Buy - Bonnell Spring Mattress Or Coir Mattress?

The bonnell spring vs coir mattress comparison is now almost complete.

On a last note, we tried to understand the experience of actual users of a bonnell spring mattress and a coir mattress.

These are the main points in our observations, the confessions from an actual user’s point-of-view:

  • Bonnell spring mattresses are not comfortable.
  • Coir mattresses are comfortable.

It is very important for a mattress buyer to base his or her judgement on comfort.

Nobody buy mattresses everyday. So it is important that the mattress you buy should be comfortable.

The mattress should not cause any health issues like back pain.

Now let us answer two common questions about a bonnell spring mattress.

First, what are the bonnell spring mattress benefits? Well, a bonnell spring mattress are durable as it is made of steel.

Second question – Is bonnell spring good for back pain? The answer is no, because a bonnell spring cannot give proper support to the pressure points. A toss and turn of another person can be felt by you if you are using a bonnell spring mattress.

The only advantage of a bonnell spring mattress is the price. Being an entry-level mattress, the bonnell spring mattress price is far lower than other type of mattresses.

But there is no reason to compromise with comfort for price, isn’t it?

Besides the above questions two other common questions are – 

Are spring mattresses good? The answer is a definite “Yes”. There is no reason for abandoning a spring mattress for the reasons given above. You can buy a good pocket spring mattress if you want one. A good pocketed spring mattress will give you a luxurious bounce as you get in the hotels.

Which mattress is best for spine? For a good support of the spine, the mattress should be responsive. So a memory foam mattress is very good for the spine as it is a responsive material. A mattress made of latex is also good for the spine as it is both responsive and natural material.

So if you are confused between buying a bonnell spring mattress and a coir mattress, we will suggest you to buy a coir mattress.

A coir mattress will definitely not cause any health problems compared to a bonnell mattress.

We would also recommend you to buy the Extra Sleep Premium coir mattress as it is a very good coir mattress at a very cheap price.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Mattress Ebook

Get FREE Mattress Buying Guide

Thank You

Please confirm your email.

Click on the link in the email to confirm your subscription.