Spring Mattress Vs Coir Foam Mattress – 2 Important Factors For Buying

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp

QUICK COMPARISON

Prices and images pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

The spring mattress vs coir foam mattress test is to find out the answer to a common question – Which one is better – a spring mattress or a coir mattress? A spring mattress is found everywhere – from hotels to home. And we obviously want a comfortable mattress for ourselves – just like the hotels, isn’t it? So let’s find out which one of the two we should choose for our home.

The Spring Mattress Vs Coir Foam Mattress Test

A spring mattress is very diffferent to a coir mattress.

The primary material in a spring mattress, the springs, are made of metal.

The primary material in a coir mattress, the coir, is made from coconut husk.

So a coir mattress is a natural product while a spring mattress is not a natural product.

There are however a similarity between a spring mattress and a coir mattress.

There are many advantages of a coir mattress. One of the main advantage of a coir mattress is that, they do not cause any health problems like allergies.

A spring mattress also do not cause any health problems like allergies.

One of the major coir mattress disadvantages is that they do not last long.

But the major difference between a spring mattress and a coir mattress is how they react to body weight. Which one is more comfortable for us? Does spring mattress cause back pain?

We have taken two mattresses for our test – the Comforto pocket spring mattress and the Extra Sleep coir mattress – to find out the answers.

Full Test

We will now conduct 6 tests on the Comforto pocket spring mattress and the Extra Sleep coir mattress to find out which one is suitable for us.

These tests will help us to find out the difference between spring and foam mattress.

The test will also help us to find out which one of the two – a spring mattress and a coir mattress – is more suitable for us.

Test 1

Material

“Comforto” is the brand name of Coir Comfort Industries (India) Private Limited, New Delhi. It is an ISO 9001:2015 certified company. It is supplying raw materials to various mattress manufacturing companies for the last 38 years. They manufacture the pocket springs themselves at their own factory. The pocket springs and the fabric quality are very good.

4/5

Extra Sleep is based in Gurgaon. The mattress is made of natural coir. The mattress has 4 layers – the coir at the middle, soft PU foam on the top of the coir, high-density foam at the base and the cotton fabric which covers the mattres. The coir, the foams and the fabric are of good quality.

4/5

WinnerThe score is a tie.

Test 2

Comfort

The Comforto pocket spring mattress is soft.

4/5

The Extra Sleep coir mattress feels firm.

5/5

Winner

The Extra Sleep coir mattress wins the round as the comfort is as per coir mattress standards.

Test 3

Sizes

The Comforto pocket spring mattress is available in 23 readymade sizes. The mattress is available in two thicknesses – 8″ and 10″.

3/5

The Extra sleep coir mattress is available in 70 readymade sizes. The mattress is available in 3 thicknesses – 4″, 5″ and 6″

4/5

Winner

The Extra Sleep mattress have more readymade sizes and thickness choices.

Test 4

Strength

The Comforto pocket spring mattress feels solid. The stitches are good.

4/5

The Extra Sleep mattress looks and feels very tough too.

4/5

Winner

The score is a tie.

Test 5

Warranty

The Comfor pocket spring mattress has only 11 years warranty. But it actually have 1 year of full warranty and 10 years of pro-rata based warranty.

2/5

The Extra Sleep coir mattress have 5 years warranty. 

4/5

Winner

The Extra Sleep mattress wins again.

Test 6

Customer Support

The customers of the Comforto mattresses are happy with their customer support.

4/5

Most of the customers of Extra Sleep are satisfied with the customer service.

4/5

Winner

The score is a tie again.

Test Result

Comforto Pocket Spring Mattress
Average Score 70%
Extra Sleep Coir Mattress
Average Score 83.3%

The winner is the Extra Sleep coir mattress.

It also proves that a coir mattress is better than a spring mattress.

Spring Mattress Vs Coir Foam Mattress Comparison

Spring Mattress

Pros

  • Material
  • Strength
  • Customer Support

Cons

  • Comfort
  • Size
  • Warranty

Coir Foam Mattress

Pros

  • Material
  • Comfort
  • Size
  • Strength
  • Warranty
  • Customer Support

Cons

  • None

Conclusion

A coir mattress is a natural product while a spring mattress is made metal.

A spring mattress is suitable for people who like a bouncy surface for sleeping. A spring mattress is more suitable for young people.

A coir mattress has a firm surface. A coir mattress gives a good firm support to the body.

The Extra Sleep coir mattress is made of coir and latex foam.

The coir and latex combination in the Extra Sleep coir mattress is excellent for giving a proper support to the body.

The coir gives a firm support to our body. The latex is a responsive material which reacts to our body pressure. It moulds to the contours of the body.

The Extra Sleep with a combination of coir and latex is very good example of a medium firm mattress. It is an excellent coir foam orthopaedic mattress.

So here are the two important factors which you should consider when choosing between a spring mattress vs coir foam mattress:

  • Which mattress gives a good support to the body?
  • Which mattress is good in terms of warranty and customer support?

As we have found out from our test, Extra Sleep coir mattress is the answer to the questions above.

The price difference is huge too when comparing a spring mattress and a coir mattress.

The Extra Sleep is way cheaper than the Comforto pocket spring mattress.

With all the goodness of a natural material, Extra Sleep coir mattress should be your choice, if you are comparing between a spring and a coir mattress.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Mattress Ebook

Get FREE Mattress Buying Guide

Thank You

Please confirm your email.

Click on the link in the email to confirm your subscription.